Navigating the Soft Commercial Real Estate Market: How to Respond in 2025 and Plan Ahead for Multifamily Success in 2026

In 2025, the commercial real estate landscape, particularly in the multifamily sector, presents a fascinating paradox: robust long-term fundamentals juxtaposed against short-term market softness. Elevated interest rates, cap rate expansion, tighter lending conditions, and oversupply in select markets have shifted the dynamics, leaving investors, developers, and operators pondering the same question: “What’s the smart play in a soft market?”

Rather than retreating, forward-thinking operators are leveraging this moment to strategically reposition their assets and operations. Here’s a comprehensive look at the current state of the multifamily market, the challenges it faces, and actionable strategies to thrive in 2025 and beyond.

The Multifamily Market in 2025: Key Indicators of Softness

The multifamily sector is grappling with several challenges that have tempered growth:

1. Elevated Interest Rates: Despite the Federal Reserve signaling a pause on rate hikes, borrowing costs remain high, curbing acquisition and refinancing activity.

   
   

2. Cap Rate Expansion: Rising cap rates are suppressing property values, creating valuation gaps between buyers and sellers.

   
   

3. Reduced Transaction Volume: Many deals are stalled as stakeholders struggle to reconcile pricing expectations.

   
   

4. Oversupply in Certain Markets: Rapid development in Sunbelt cities like Austin, Nashville, and Phoenix has led to excess inventory, rent stagnation, and concessions.

   
   

5. Insurance and Operating Cost Inflation: Escalating insurance premiums and property taxes are squeezing net operating income (NOI).

Despite these headwinds, medium- and long-term demand fundamentals remain strong, underscoring the potential for future growth.

Strategies for Multifamily Success in a Soft Market

To navigate the current environment, operators must adopt disciplined, strategic approaches.

Here are six key strategies:

1. Focus on Operational Efficiency

When rent growth decelerates, optimizing NOI becomes crucial. Operators should:

• Perform energy audits to lower utility expenses.

• Vigorously shop for insurance and consider master policies.

• Utilize technology to automate leasing and maintenance processes.

• Enhance resident retention to reduce expensive turnover.

Even small improvements in expense management of 5–10% can significantly boost cash flow in a low-growth setting.

2. Reassess the Capital Stack

The capital markets have evolved, rendering aggressive underwriting ineffective. Strategic operators should:

• Restructure loans before they mature.

• Explore preferred equity or mezzanine debt for transaction recapitalization.

• Consider seller financing or assuming low-interest loans for acquisitions.

Modeling deals with higher exit cap rates, lower leverage, and realistic rent growth will provide a competitive edge.

3. Lean Into Value-Add Opportunities

Although the traditional value-add model has changed, it still holds potential. Operators should concentrate on:

• Minor renovations with high returns on investment, such as improvements in lighting, flooring, and curb appeal.

• Repositioning amenities, for instance, transforming business centers into co-working lounges.

• Improving maintenance and unit readiness to reduce downtime.

  
  

Conservative underwriting and careful execution are crucial for success throughout the rest of 2025.

4. Target Underserved Renter Segments

While Class A urban markets may be experiencing an oversupply, there is a growing demand in:

• Workforce housing, including Class B and C properties.

• Suburban rental communities.

• Mixed-income housing backed by public-private partnerships.

• Single-family rental models converting to multifamily units.

It will be crucial to understand local renter profiles and provide options that offer affordability, flexibility, and a sense of community.

5. Invest in Technology and Data

In a competitive market, making decisions based on data is crucial. Operators should utilize PropTech platforms for:

• Rent benchmarking within specific submarkets.

• Tracking and attributing leads.

• Analytics at the portfolio level.

• Scheduling predictive maintenance.

Operators who rely on data to make decisions in micro-markets will surpass competitors who depend on outdated instincts.

6. Position for the Next Upswing

Real estate cycles are temporary, with downturns frequently leading to significant recoveries. Operators should:

• Accumulate capital reserves for upcoming acquisitions.

• Enhance connections with lenders and brokers.

• Keep an eye on distressed seller activity and zoning changes to identify future opportunities.

  
  

Focusing on the next 3–5 years, instead of just the upcoming 12 months, will secure long-term success.

Where the Opportunities Lie in 2025

Real estate is inherently local, and certain markets offer better prospects than others.

Watch for:

• Midwest Cities: Stable populations and low volatility (e.g., Kansas City, Columbus, Indianapolis).

• Secondary Sunbelt Markets: Areas that have avoided oversupply (e.g., Greenville, SC; Chattanooga, TN).

• Tertiary Growth Markets: Locations near universities or healthcare hubs.

• Urban Neighborhoods: Areas ripe for long-term revitalization.

Preparing for Success in 2026

The multifamily sector faces a dynamic environment in 2026, marked by high renter demand but soft rental growth, rising costs, and expanding cap rates. Strategic planning will be essential to navigate financing challenges, operational margins, and value-driven opportunities. Success hinges on understanding market trends, adapting to softness, and positioning assets for long-term growth.

Elements That Will Persist in Causing Multifamily Market Weakness in 2026

1. Lingering High Interest Rates: Elevated borrowing costs impact refinancing, acquisitions, and valuations.

2. Oversupply in Select Markets: Construction from 2021–2023 results in absorption delays and slower rent growth, especially in Sunbelt cities.

3. Insurance, Taxes & Operating Costs: Rising expenses outpace revenue growth, cutting into NOI.

4. Cap Rate Expansion: Adjusted investor expectations are pushing asset values downward.

Strategic Planning for Multifamily Success in 2026

1. Operational Excellence: Reduce variable costs, enhance tenant retention, and tighten vacancy processes for improved NOI.

2. Refinancing Preparation: Stress test assets, engage lenders early, and explore alternative financing structures.

3. Value-Based Investing: Target secondary and tertiary markets, under-managed assets, and workforce housing with clear upside potential.

4. Data-Driven Decisions: Leverage real-time insights for lease trade-outs, renewal trends, and predictive analytics.

5. Renovation Adjustments: Focus on practical upgrades aligned with tenant preferences and ROI.

6. Cautious Distress Investments: Prioritize clean, well-located assets with manageable risks and clear opportunities.

7. Long-Term Positioning: Build for the next cycle, focusing on demographic-driven markets and resilient multifamily assets.

Market Outlook for 2026

• Urban Class A: Soft; time acquisitions post-lease-up.

• Suburban B/C: Stable; ideal for value-add strategies.

• Sunbelt Secondary: Mixed; focus on employment growth and supply constraints.

• Midwest Tertiary: Strong; stable cash flow and long-term holds.

Final Thoughts: Strategy Over Sentiment

Although the rest of 2025 & heading into 2026 might present a blend of market stability, it also provides chances for recalibration, disciplined underwriting, and proactive asset management. Those operators who adapt, manage expenses, and utilize data effectively will prosper amid uncertainty and spearhead the next cycle.

Success depends on execution, not hesitation—prepare your business now for growth.

DC & Mox

The information provided on this website is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be considered as personalized advice. It is recommended that you seek professional guidance tailored to your specific requirements. The views expressed are solely those of the authors, and Moxie Consults does not accept responsibility for third-party opinions. Please refrain from sharing confidential information until a service agreement has been established. The content on this site is not guaranteed to be accurate or comprehensive and should not be interpreted as financial, legal, or any other form of professional advice. Links to external websites are included for convenience and do not imply endorsement or accountability by Moxie Consults for their content. The use of this website does not guarantee specific outcomes. All materials on the site are either owned by or licensed to Moxie Consults and are protected by copyright laws. Moxie Consults reserves the right to modify information without prior notification. Users are responsible for keeping themselves updated. By using the website, users agree to release Moxie Consults from any liability. This disclaimer is governed by the laws of Colorado.